Skip to main content

Truth and...Orville (?)

When I climbed on this soapbox, I had intended to take a lofty, high minded intellectual view.
Alas...
Last night I was watching the TV Show "Orville" episode 7 "Majority Rule" and it spoke to exactly the ideas I've been thinking about, so I couldn't resist sharing it. Orville, a Seth MacFarlane project, is a humorous take on Star Trek.  Obviously, spoilers ahead...

Majority Rule

Imagine a society guided by an absolute democracy.
The population can vote yes or no on everything. There are no fixed laws. Actually, the only laws guide how votes are organized. At the age of 18, all citizens are issued and required to wear a little gadget on their chest with an up or down button and a running counts of "likes" vs "dislikes".  At some level (500,000 dislikes ?) individuals start to lose rights - like service at a cafe. At a very high level of 10 million dislikes, "criminals by acclimation" are required to undergo lobotomy-like re-education.

Consider these examples:

  • Somebody compliments how good you look - you press his "like" button.
  • Somebody likes the blog you just wrote - "like". 
  • Somebody insults you - "dislike"
  • Somebody give you poor service - "dislike".
so far so good.  If fact, this seems pretty familiar. However, what about these;
  • Somebody says something you don't like - "dislike"
  • Somebody says something you disagree with -"dislike"
  • Somebody states a fact that you don't like - "dislike"
If this happens enough,  there are consequences.  In fact, if the speaker states those inconvenient truths two much, they can be censured and previous facts become  falsehoods aka "FAKE NEWS".
What about these...
  • Everyone votes on what foods are healthy and what are dangerous. 
  • Everyone votes on what medical practices are most effective.
  • Everyone votes on which economic policies are most effective. 
In other words, everyone's opinion is equally valid and everyone is an expert. 

Of course, in the story, the crew of the Orville decide this is a terrible situation, but given some "prime directive" kind of view of the universe they are prohibited from intervening.  Unfortunately, one of their members gets caught up in the system and faces a citizen vote driven threat of lobotomy. 
Where I found the episode to be especially challenging, however, was the way in which the Captain intervened to rescue his crew member. Rather than allow the crewman to face the unacceptably  extreme consequences of his admittedly ill-advised actions,  the Captain figures out what images and actions would sway public sentiment and then literally manufactures those images and floods the media with them. To rescue the crew man, he produced "Fake News" to sway the public opinion. 

The real problem with this kind of society wasn't so much the way it was working, but the way it could be manipulated and perverted, and this was done by people who saw themselves as superior to it. 

Again, this is very similar to our current situation in America.  Democracy is based on beautiful principles. 
Churchill once said " Many forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.…"
However, at some point individuals within the government, think they are above it. They think the purpose are superior, and thus manipulating and perverting the system itself is justified...

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why are Autumn Leaves so colorful?

Most people know, at least in broad brush strokes, HOW? autumn leaves turn out to be so colorful. I was wondering WHY? and Why so many colors? Just to clear up the HOW? part... At the most general level, when the weather turns colder, deciduous (leafy) trees stop making green pigment and the remaining underlying colors are revealed. More specifically, as the in the late summer, the veins in leafy trees start to constrict and the production of the compound responsible for photosynthesis, chlorophyll, is down regulated through the reduction of a single protein FtsH6. As the chlorophyll synthesis is reduced, the remaining chlorophyll is converted to a colorless set of compounds called NCCs (nonfluorescent chlorophyll catabolites) As the chlorophyll ebbs, three specific pigments are revealed: Carotonids are the yellow and orange colors in leaves. They are present all year long and concentrated in structures called plastids. Note that this is a class of compounds and lots of the yellow co
Post a Comment
Read more

Truth

truth NOUN [mass noun]            Origin: Old English trīewth, trēowth ‘faithfulness, constancy’ 1 The quality or state of being true. ‘he had to accept the truth of her accusation’ 1.1 (also  the truth ) That which is true or in accordance with fact or reality. ‘tell me the truth’ ‘she found out the truth about him’ 1.2 [count noun] A fact or belief that is accepted as true. ‘the emergence of scientific truths’ ‘the fundamental truths about mankind’ It is no secret to anyone who knows me that I extremely critical of the Trump Regime.  However, if I am honest, I think that Donald Trump is a symptom a deeply divided society, not the cause of it.   I have a new soapbox... The fundamental, basic characteristic of this divide is our societies' tenuous relationship with the concept of TRUTH.  I'm not sure yet if this is a cause or symptom, but its deeply involved.  I decided to put some thought in to this and consider what we mean by TRUTH. The definitio
Post a Comment
Read more

Logical Fallacies

I love Logical Fallacies. Well, to be clear,  I love the idea of Logical Fallacies, specifically the fact that over the ages people have analyzed and classified the many ways that individuals can intentionally, or unconsciously and unintentionally, make argue in illogical or misleading ways. For my benefit, I thought I would write a series of essays evaluating the different classes and specifics of Logical Fallacies. Since the time of the greeks and romans Logic, Rhetoric and Philosophy were formal subjects of study in every well rounded education. As we all recall from school, the first step to teach anything is break it down into little pieces and then group all the pieces together as you try and reconstruct the whole.  Speaking as a biochemist, I have to admit this doesn't always work that well, but following in the footsteps of the ancients, let's give that a try. Formal Logical Fallacies In the sub-discipline of Philosophy concerned with logic, in order to be conside
Post a Comment
Read more